Monday, January 28, 2013

IB English Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil Chunk #1 Response


Foreshadowing: Jim Williams

“…I keep pistols in strategic places. There's a Luger in the rear library, another in a desk drawer in my office, a third in the Irish linen press in the hall, and a Smith and Wesson in the living room. I've also got a shotgun and three or four rifles upstairs. The pistols are loaded.
‘That's four loaded pistols,’ I said.
‘There's a risk, I know. But I'm a gambler’” (Berendt 21).

I think that this quote shows foreshadowing. Although Berendt’s book is technically classified as nonfiction (and even this is debated), he makes use of several techniques commonly seen in novels, one of which is foreshadowing. The above quote discusses how Jim Williams keeps many (loaded) guns in his house for protection. However, based on what the readers see of Savannah, this is not entirely necessary. For example, Joe Odom never shuts the doors to his residence. Even if a firearm deterrent were needed, one or two guns would be plenty. Since Jim Williams has all of these guns in his house, the chances that he will use a gun at least some point in the story seems likely. In addition, Williams admits that it is a risk, but he is a gambler. Unfortunately, a gambler will eventually run out of luck. Due to all of this, I think that there will be a tragic accident involving Jim Williams and his gun(s) somewhere later on in the story.

Does anyone agree or disagree with my opinion? In addition, since the book is “nonfiction”, do you think this part of the book is germane to today’s debates about gun control?